Wednesday, November 4, 2009

BeerWare


BeerWare is stuff that will get you a free-as-beer beer on my tab if you give me a hand with it.

Typically it's stuff that calls for skills or resources I don't have handy, yet I suspect would be worth doing and for the sake of more than little me, if differently-able folks were to take a shot at it.

Stuff tagged as such, to date: Linky.

Teh list:

***

Tuesday, November 3, 2009

Alliance Starbase Charters

I like the idea of Starbase Charters, it's a clever way to tax POS operations while tying mission runners into the industrial loop and general market…

Let's take it one step further and allow territorial alliances to issue their own Starbase Charters, that would be required to run a POS in their sovereign space.
Not only does it create a revenue stream for alliances to support their infrastructural costs, and formalizes their relationship as landlords with residents, but it basically gives sovereign alliances the power to mint their own currency !

I'll let you work out the implications it could have in terms of launching POSes in non-friendly 0.0 with two words: contraband much ?

Going all Dutch on the CSM

This will probably end in tears, somehow, but it's interesting.

No further comments, just go check it for yourself, I dare you.

Monday, November 2, 2009

Dicing the blob (part 1)

As seen earlier, the nature of fleet commander as a role makes counter-intuitive to trust anyone's judgement but his own to make the right decisions.

Under pressure to think fast and account for many factors simultaneously, Fleet Commanders also face the responsibility for any losses their fleet incurs, and potentially the blame for defeat. A natural response of some people to that kind of stress is to let their inner control-freak grab the weel in an attempt to bring a semblance of order to a chaotic situation. For better or worse, the type of people who end up commanding fleets usually host such an inner monster, gnawing on its chain and waiting any opportunity to take over.

Not even the worst control freak will attempt to micromanage a combat group of 40 pilots, however, much less a 300+ men fleet, so the next best thing is to wield the entire gang like a gigantic mace, and go for the application of maximum force on a single point as a straightforward way to bring the pain to the enemy.

For being crude, this tactic is fairly effective when going for reasonably static and large targets on an open field, which is precisely the sort one faces in nullsec territorial warfare, both pre and in Dominion: outposts and various sovereignty flagpoles and switches (POS and modules, HUBs, FLAGs and STOPs) all qualify.
Because all parties involved have to conveniently rally around these hotspots in a fairly predictable sequence, the ability to apply as much brute force as possible on short notice to a suitably ranged and sized enemy fleet is also deemed beneficial.
In the absence of other incentives to do so, splitting the fleet into discrete, semi-autonomous wings or squads brings no sizable benefit for the price of a steep increase in perceived complexity and uncertainty for the Fleet Commanders.

Thus, the option of hurling a single giant ball of pain in the general direction of the enemy is too tempting to pass,

…and a blob is born.
No matter how much everybody hates the blob, no alliance leader in EVE is prepared to lose a territorial battle, not too mention a war, for the sole sake of style or giving their fighters a good time: 0.0 selects unusually competitive players for leadership, who will go to any length to win. As long as game mechanics support blobbing as the most readily available winning strategy, it will remain the prevalent model for all warring territorial alliances.

There are two obvious ways to flush the blob off its N°1 place on the podium: nerf it, or boost other strategies.

Nerfing is the first impulse of the angered game designer when facing pesky players who soil his pristine vision by squirting 'emergence' all over the place. But the blob is not a design feature as much as it is an adaptation of the players' strategies to the game mechanics, and as such can't be directly nerfed: as long as throwing more and bigger ships at the same problem increases the odds of solving it, alliances will keep doing exactly that.

Plan B is to introduce counters, or rather intended penalties to deter FCs from relying on blobs: the titan doomsday and mothership Projected ECCM burst were in their time touted as anti-blob weapons.
Projected ECCMs proven largely unusable due to flawed design, while the titan doomsdays were met first by bigger blobs (due to the DPS penalty imposed on regular ships by the new 'requirement' to tank doomsdays) then by an arms race for doomsday firepower resulting in… titan blobs ! Way to go.
Although better 'counters' could be devised, they are unlikely to put sufficient pressure on strategists and FCs for them to let go of a proven and convenient strategy as long as no significantly better alternative is available to them.

That leaves Plan C:
cook up the books
…so that other tactics beat the blob to a squish.

The mission objective is now clear: design territorial warfare mechanics such as a fleet divided into many autonomous small combat groups (squad sized whenever possible, and never bigger than a wing each) can reasonably out-perform one or two blobs tallying twice its player count when attacking, and thrice when defending sovereign space.

[The requirement for even higher better-than-blob performance in defense is there to account for the fact most territorial invasions are only attempted when the attackers are reasonably confident in their numerical superiority, and the defenders usually make do with what they have at the time — if we want wing/squad-centric strategies to prove inherently superior to blobbing, they must remain so under those exceedingly unfavorable numeric odds.]



Here's how to do it:
  • Force differentiation and variety:
    Blobbing relies on simplicity and homogeneity, and blobs are giant meatshields spewing a lot of DPS. As such, they favor the largest affordable ships with the most damage output available: BSes in a cyno-jammed system, then capitals. Shaping the battlegrounds so that a diversity of ship classes get the advantage in the course of a single battle will see an homogeneous blob more frequently on the wrong foot than the good one compared to a mixed formation.

  • Multiply simultaneous hotspots:
    Even in an open field battle, there is such a thing as overkill. If 40 BSes are shooting the same primary BS, it will be vaporized before most of the collective alpha-strike is accounted for. By multiplying the hotspots for simultaneous action, an edge is given to the fleet who can sensibly divide and assign its numbers to separate targets.
    Dominion goes a step in the right direction with the idea of occupying stargates to unlock access to sovereignty flagpoles, then shoots its forward foot by using anchorables with hard-timers for that (see below).

  • Get rid of hard timers:
    Hard timers are the most blob-friendly design elements one can imagine, especially when they are known of everybody.
    Not only do hard timers set a date in advance for all to meet over a single hotspot (a.k.a a blobfest), but they increase the efficiency of blobbing by supporting steamroll strategies: once a hard-timer is triggered, there's typically nothing much anyone can do around this hotspot until the countdown runs out, which means a blob is free to move on to the next target to trigger its timer, etc.
    Speedbumps are necessary to mitigate timezone metagaming, but they can revolve around dynamic decay/recharge rates, or conditions that can be modified by players' actions. One of many ways to pace a rapetrain, for ex, is to require of the conquerors to consolidate/maintain their hold over seized sovereignty flags/switches — lest they revert to the defenders.

  • Finer grained sovereignty with stronger defensive benefits:
    This is roughly the opposite of what Dominion proposes, as it would mean you can start gaining significant sovereignty below the solar system level (planetary sounds good), with the possibility of several sovereignties coexisting/competing within a single solar system.
    This allows to significantly boost defensive benefits of sovereignty across the board, as they would not only benefit the system defenders, but also the attackers — provided they manage to gain a foothold on a planet and consolidate it (see above the hard-timers issue).
    Finer-grained sovereignty without hard timers also means several semi-independant sovereignty battles can rage simultaneously in a system, further increasing the benefits of splitting the blob and adding depth to territorial warfare tactics.

  • Long-distance relationships:
    We can make it work… EVE is not Starcraft, each solar system is not supposed to be a map entirely disconnected from the rest of the universe. Sovereignty at the constellation scale not only adds context, but the status of solar systems directly surrounding a battlefield should inform the strategy and objectives of competing alliances.
    Strengthen the sovereignty defenses of systems deeply embedded in friendly space, and you create an incentive for attackers to attack from the outside-in, on multiple fronts whenever possible. Require that stargates be seized on both 'sides' of a jump to trigger the switch you need to access an enemy flagpole in a coveted system, and separate combat groups are needed to watch over them. All those options are available at minimal server load costs to encourage or force strategists to spread their armies over more ground.

  • Separate sovereignty contests from pew-pew:
    Another thing CCP half-heartedly tries in Dominion with disruptor fields, only to shoot its other foot by bringing pew-pew back in.
    In EVE, establishing sovereignty has always been about raising flagpole structures, yet challenging sovereignty is — in Dominion more than ever — about destroying said structures, not capturing them.
    What if it was possible to take over a sovereignty flagpole by hacking the airlocks to drop in a bunch of Marines and Exotic Dancers, plus a few crates of moonshine, while the owners are suitably distracted ? What if disabling or taking over a flagpole or a stargate depended on mounting and using special equipment on your ship, rather than shooting a barn ?
This last bit is the topic of the next entry in this series, but downtime is over, go do something useless.

Sunday, November 1, 2009

Putting the RTT in Rah-Tah-Tah ! (part 2)

[Continued from part 1]

I had lasagna, it was good, thank you.
Both my stomach and heart are heavy now, as I contemplate the sad fate of the overwhelming majority of players in territorial warfare, reduced to roleplay the cattle in a game of stampede for the sake of supposed Epic-ness.

So, how do we reverse the trend and bring that dreadful 1/15 ratio closer to 1/1 ?
At a glance, we can increase the proportion of players landing in the Command and RTT categories, reduce the relative headcount of grunts, or both.


The perfect fit.

Empirically, from team-oriented FPS and ball games, we can wage a good team size for each individual to matter a great deal is no more than 16, and north of 4.
Less than 5 and a single defection/incapacitation impacts your team too heavily (that's tantamount to a titan doomsdaying in the middle of a non-plated fleet) plus variety suffers (you can't cover all basic roles). Over a dozen, it becomes tricky for members of the team to maintain constant awareness of the roles, status and whereabouts of their teammmates.

That includes the team leader for which multitasking explodes into chaos when more than a few units have to be accounted for in real time, unless he/she lumps similar units together to make things easier on command — and then we go back to the faceless grunt predicament.

Luckily, EVE already provides for an in-game representation of such a team: the Squad.

At 10 members, including one Squad Commander, a squad is perfectly sized to provide for a reasonable diversity of roles and can afford some losses before losing usefulness, yet is small enough that every member counts and gets a pivotal part to play in the execution of a mission.

Ten Battleships, or carriers, or dreadnaughts or even frigates can prove to be a force to reckon with under the right circumstances, and a mixed group of various ships such as 2 pointer scouts, 2 healers, 2 tacklers and 4 heavy DPS boats could form a discrete, autonomous and flexible unit capable of many newsworthy exploits.

How comes we don't see any of those on most battlefields ? Two reasons:
  • Fleet Commanders can't be arsed to micromanage too many independent units ;
  • the numbers game makes any subtlety moot.
The second point is a huge can of worms and leads us to go after the N°1 funkiller in nullsec EVE, a.k.a the blob ecosystem, which I'll try and slice to bite-sized morsels in my next entry… For now we'll just have a look at why FCs can't handle armies of more than a few active brains, and how to address that.

FCs are in the same position any squad member or commander is: they can only keep track of so many things at once.
An upper limit for most people is between 3 and 7 items they can continuously keep track of in the course of a complex task, before the bookkeeping hogs most of their resources and they can't move anything ahead.

FCs have to account not only for their troops, but for the enemy's numbers, types and positions on the battlefield, not to mention the intel streaming constantly from afar to let them know about stuff coming their way. With that in mind, the leader of each combat group has precious little brainspace left to keep tabs on every frigate in his fleet, so the natural impulse is to reduce the part of the equation he can, and that's you.
By lumping you and the other 150 battleship pilots together into a single unit, he makes things a bit more manageable.

Of course, a Fleet Commander has a tool at his disposal to reduce complication, if not complexity, and that's the middle-rung in a fleet hierarchy: the Wing, and its Commander.
By entrusting Wing Commanders to discretely manage the minutiae of individual ship types, roles and pilots inside their unit, a Fleet Commander is blessed with no more than 5 Wings to worry about at any given time.

With each wing led by a commander, himself ruling over up to 5 squads, each squad staffed with a leader and enough team-ready brains onboard to act as a single unit, you'd expect things to go smoothly and make for a lot of opportunities for individual pilots to shine, right ?
Works for me, and would for you, too, because you'd never be a faceless grunt anymore if your combat group was guaranteed to incorporate no more than one leader and 4 to 8 other units besides yours.

Alas, Fleet Commanders don't delegate to Wing Commanders …because they usually are Wing Commanders themselves, and manage a fleet as an oversized wing.
Furthermore, most FCs have never personally flown in a formal squad, be it as leader or member.

Sounds like it would be easy enough to bring that contradiction to the FCs themsleves, but as any alliance leader will tell you: Fleet Commanders are a rare and precious breed you don't want to alienate.
Most fleet commanders are self-selected and subject to a serious case of Peter's syndrome: they got there because they could successfully lead a wing of 40-80 pilots to victory repeatedly, and are willing to take on the thankless chore of doing that every day and night in your alliance name, as long as nobody meddles with their end of the business and they're provided with enough cannon-fodder.


In non-news: Convenience beats Quality, again.
As a result, most FCs are used to lead undisciplined hordes of spacenerds which on the whole can't be relied to align in synch to a celestial, and they're not ready to bet a battle or their reputation on the odds that some of the nublets under their command may actually be able to think for themselves.

When successful wing commanders become new FCs, they enter the unforgiving rotation of 4'o'clock morning alerts on cellphone, which is enough to wear out any goodwill one may still harbor for n00b players and innovative strategies in a matter of weeks. Meanwhile, anyone who can lead an informal roaming squad is fast-tracked to FC'ing in a swim or sink fashion, without a stop by the Wing Command post, because who wants to fill a role nobody gives a crap about, given the choice ?

Along came a prophet,
…and he was promptly nailed to a door.

When the rare, the weird FC shows up who's willing to actually use Wing and Squad commanders, he's quickly discouraged by the three worst curses of initiative: inertia, lack of means, impossible expectations.
  • Inertia because other FCs don't want things to change, lest they risk being questioned about how they do stuff, and the first rule of FC'ing is: don't mess with my shit or I bail ;

  • Lack of means: because the Fleet Management tools are broken when it comes to flexibility, and organizing a fleet is so painful and time-consuming nobody wants to take the blame for forcing that unto others ;

  • Impossible expectations: as a consequence of the two points above, if you piss off the existing brass and slow down fleet formation even more than usual, you better get miracle-grade results on your first sortie, or you can expect to get planked for it.
The outcome is easy to predict: FCs are cranky and overworked as a rule, WCs are non-existent because the role doesn't exist or sucks too badly, so they bail out of nullsec alliances, along with good Squad leaders, and turn pirate or go play empire and lowsec wars, where there is room for small-scale tactics.

With the current dynamics of territorial warfare (which really is most of nullsec warfare), this sorry state of things is unlikely to evolve: it would take a radical change in game mechanics that heavily favors smarts and flexible tactics over raw numbers to authorize/force current alliance strategists and FCs out of their old ways, a question we'll look at in the next episode of this series: Dicing the blob.


Putting the RTT in Rah-Tah-Tah ! (part 1)

[Continued from part 5 on Dominion]


Today's downtime filler is about making territorial warfare fun, something that CCP has consistently failed to deliver up to now, and a tradition they clearly intend to uphold with Dominion.

To be fair, and for once cut some slack to EVE's designer team, meaningful and fun territorial warfare is a legendary creature in the general MMO lore, so CCP is more or less on its own, plowing ahead in a field most MMO companies have long abandoned.

Zoom zoom zoom.
EVE is a very ambitious design when it comes to 'zoom levels': it's a RTS, a RTT, a BigMap wargame, a grand scale galactic conquest, a political RPG and a tycoon-type game, all rolled into one. It is also incredibly successful on the whole: the extent to which each distinct playstyle adds to the depth and contextual complexity of others aspects of the game is unmatched in the current videogame market.

Unfortunately, although the whole is impressive, many of its parts are terribly lacking on their own merits, and prove worth playing only insofar as they relate to a bigger picture that helps the player cope with a mediocre to miserable gameplay.

It's probably one of the biggest issues with EVE territorial warfare — besides not being a very exciting and fun RTS to begin with — that it's only worth playing as a commander or strategist, yet game mechanics force the huge majority of players to play roles a NPC wouldn't gladly take.

The RTS map of sovereignty warfare.
A glance at the typical territorial battleground in EVE is enough to see why that is: the array of roles available for players to fill breaks down to a handful: grunt, capital grunt, scout, capital tackler, healer, then elite unit (pointer scouts and supercaps), fleet commander, capital fleet commander, strategist.
OK, that's two handfuls + 1.
Sounds diverse enough ? I agree, it would, if not for the fact that the overwhelming majority of the head count will be crammed into two roles: grunts… and capital grunts.

Let's break it down with numbers:

Command:
  • Strategist: 1
  • Capital Fleet Commander: 1 (rarely 2)
  • Fleet Commander: 1-2 (sometimes 3)
  • Pointer scouts: 1-5 per combat group
  • Capital Tacklers: 1-3 teams of 1-5 each (sometimes embedded in the regular fleets)

Combat groups:
  • Healers: 1 team of 1-5 each per combat group (sometimes embedded in the combat group)
  • Supercapitals: 0-10 (likely to be merged into the regular capital fleet, post Dominion)
  • Capitals: 1-2 fleets of 20 to all you can field (typically around 30-50 each).
  • Subcapitals: 1-3 fleets of 100 to all you can field (typically between 150 and 400 each).

Back of the envelope maths:
  • Command: 4-6 (1 strategist, 1-2 cap FC, 2-3 FC)
  • RTT teams: 27, or 37 generously assuming the healers aren't handled as a single unit per team (13 pointer scouts, 5 supercaps, 6 cap tacklers, 13 healers)
  • Grunts: 500+ (60 caps, 450 BS)
To make things easy, let's assume for now a sufficient condition for a role to be fun is for it to be meaningful, and define meaningful in this context as a role where one more or less player doing his job well is enough to be tactically decisive. In simpler terms, your role is deemed fun to play if your individual skill and decisions can change the outcome at a tactical level.

Furthermore, let's state the obvious and say it: playing a grunt (a.k.a cannon fodder) is not brimming full of meaning from the player's standpoint.

Now it gets scary. By the above back-of-the-envelope calculations:
  • 1 player out of 110 is in a command position (meaningful ? check).
  • 1 player out of 17 (closer to 20 really, but who's counting…) is in a Real-time Tactical position (meaningful ? Mostly. Almost always fun).
That's one player for fifteen who's having a shot at making a difference in the course of a territorial battle, which doesn't look so bad, until you realize it translates to over 93% of participants virtually sitting on the bench for having no measurable personal influence whatsoever, regardless of their skill, smarts or dedication, nor what may be at stake for them in the battle (like losing your home station/system).


Saturday, October 31, 2009

Islands in the net.


[Continued from part 4 on Dominion]


Editor's note: Damn, I was on time today, but the intarweb devils didn't let me access blogger, so for the 5 of you checking daily, you're not crazy: I indeed faked the post time by about 5 hours. Thanks for waiting.

Imagine, if you will, nullsec as a vast tropical sea, each solar system a shallow-depth volcanic raise reaching up from the bottom of the oceans to mere feet below the surface, each constellation a loose archipelago, each sun a radiant pool of peaceful water surrounded by the reef of planets rising just high enough above sea-level to draw the shape of a lagoon — add dolphins to taste.

Dreamy, ain't it ? Let me fix myself a suitable drink, real quick.

There… where was I ? Right, space lagoon:

Comes a ship flotilla, a nomadic sailing tribe of settlers, captains and engineers, bringing with them tools, building materials and hungry stomachs from the faraway drylands of Empire…

Soon enough, the colonial ships are moored just outside the lagoon, break out rowboats, and sailors start fishing in the shallow, warm waters where swarms of timid but unsuspecting creatures are easily caught to feed the starving crews. Meanwhile, the engineers get hard at work, building simple pontoons at first, then, later on, cranes and forges to dig out from the volcanic reef precious ores that will be melted to forge more fishing hooks, tools and weapons, while the mining waste is dumped nearby to raise more ground above sea-level.

Mere weeks later, the lagoon can now be seen from miles at sea, thanks to the smoking chimneys of stilts-raised huts, the masts and the longshoremen cranes that peak high over the now-continuous crescent of banked rocks. No longer a desert, a new dryland is born in this archipelago — by all definitions of the term, an outpost.

I'd carry the metaphor with the sailboats further, but we'd need to wait for trees to grow on our artificial islands, and that'd take longer than we can spare on this article, so I'll just run you through the high-level picture of what happens next, because that's the relevant bit.

  • People on the lagoon quickly eat most of the fish around, plus the fish tends to get annoyed by all the noisy locals and by being eaten so much, so there's less of it — fish.

  • Good news is, our settlers now have the means to build fast, nimble boats and routinely venture to nearby reef archipelagos where the fish is plenty, and the occasional digging of volcanic rocks and sand doesn't frighten the food longer than the time it will take before the fishermen return on their next fishing campaign.

  • Smartly, our settlers decide not to colonize those other lagoons and reefs, in order to keep a steady source of fish and other materials handy.

  • One day, however, a fishing expedition runs into unknown sloops, who seem bent on forbidding them their usual fishing waters ! After some cursing and a burned down ketch, the intruders are repelled.

  • As time goes by, such incidents become increasingly common, until eventually a fishing party is forced to race home to the outpost lagoon, chased by foreign boats most definitely rigged to sink ships rather than trawl shrimps.

  • Decision is made to erect some catapults on the lagoon's banks, to escort all fishing parties with ballistas-equipped schooners, and to start actively going after the intruders.
I reckon you can tell where it goes from here…



Un-screwing things one at a time.
Can you spot the differences between Dominion and this picture ?
  • Colonized space is easier to defend, supports and enables critical industry, and provides reasonably secure housing of goods, equipment and people, but quickly runs short on natural resources to gather and exploit.

  • Wild space can't readily be protected against intrusion and interference from competing groups, but is resource-rich, and as such precious enough to defend by active patrolling, as are your group's gatherers.

  • The optimal strategy for any newly established territorial alliance is to pack infrastructure where it can be defended, while limiting the infrastructural sprawl over hunter-gatherer space, and to preserve wild areas close to the colony to minimize the length and risk of trips to the hunting grounds.

  • As the size of a colony grows, it can seed new colonies remote enough from the first settlement(s) to preserve interstitial hunting grounds, or expand the core colony at the cost of requiring a larger band of wild lands around it to keep resources coming, and with the corollary displacement of the hunter-gatherers population's residence toward the fringes of the territory.


Protip to CCP:

Strong defensive and industrial benefits should come from developing high levels of sovereignty and infrastructure, which should incur heavy penalties for local PvE resources.

Keep true-sec as it is, significantly boost base wealth in conquerable null-sec, make loot/spawn tables adjust dynamically (downward) based on local infrastructure, average population, local and surrounding sovereignty 'score' (which conversely boost and enable industry/defense perks), and you have a system that gives the edge to small-medium alliances built on a well-coordinated mix of PvPers and industrialists over sprawling herds of PvE hunter-gatherers, while forcing codependency between both styles, and creating interesting friction areas in the interstitial, richer wild lands.


Yes, I too am impressed by the skill CCP displays in doing it exactly back-asswards.


[Tomorrow, unless I get distracted, I'll show you how to make sovereignty warfare fun with sand fortresses — no kidding.]



Friday, October 30, 2009

Monkeys in my cogs.

Today's dt filler is late and really filler-like, as in I didn't find a (sober) moment to finish writing something half-worth the read, thanks to some Champagne-fueled farewell partying last night.

For a different take on Dominion, I suggest you, the reader, sink your teeth in that very relevant couple posts from Aralis, of CVA fame.
[Full disclaimer: I don't have any personal history, good or bad, in-game or out with Aralis or CVA. I also don't necessarily endorse or condone Aralis' views — in fact, I don't share his opinions on quite a few topics, including in relation to Dominion, but I find his perspective both pertinent and stimulating.]
Seriously, read it — I honestly would have linked to those posts in today's article, had I managed to write something decent.

Thursday, October 29, 2009

Occam's backhoe

I've been thinking hard about it, and I've narrowed the possible causes for the apparent ineptitude of everything 0.0 in Dominion to three, non mutually exclusive options. Here they are, listed in decreasing order of likeliness, and growing order of comedic value.
  • The Star Trek 'tech' hypothesis.
    CCP devs went, for each individual change/fix, with the very first idea that crossed their mind. Then, come dev blog time, they break out the jargon book, and spray semi-random technobabble and pseudo-scientific lingo on top of the disaster, in the vain hope to retroactively cover their mess with a varnish of intellectual authority.
  • The instant great thinking: just add water !
    Each dev got individually assigned a single theme or buzzword in economics, philosophy, game design, or social sciences, with strict instructions to grasp no more than 1/12th of its implications, and run with it as the single cornerstone of their design. Dev blogs are executed according to the exact same rules.
  • Crazy-brilliant madness.
    They know exactly what they're doing, and they're simply shooting for the Guiness Book world record of trollage by design.
…and then, of course there's beer, but it's kinda lame to blame your tools for your poor craftsmanship.

I'd start a betting pool if I knew how to ascertain the rankings. Any ideas welcome.

Wednesday, October 28, 2009

Dominion Part 4 — the good, if elusive, bits.

[Continued from part 3 on Dominion]

After three rounds spent pounding on CCP for their drunken attempt at fixing nullsec, it's only fair to give our Icelandic overlords the praise they deserve for the good bits floating atop the Dominion soup.

The most promising additions are of the facilitating/enabling stripes, meaning stuff that doesn't rest on any specific expectation of CCP about how spacenerds should play EVE, but rather on devs acknowledging what can help users to play at all.

EVEmail, now with (much less) suck.
The mail is quick enough to cover, it's sort of a circa-1998 mail client, but in game !
If that's not a big deal for you, you never had to endure the current 'mail' system in EVE, and I recommend you go have a look now, so you can fully enjoy the bliss of finally getting tech from the last century in our gooey podpilot hands.
Beyond that, there are words about this thing somehow being accessible from outside the game, at least in read mode, which is a giant step in the right direction (although we've no idea whether it will really make it in Dominion in any functional shape of form) and brings us to…

New Eden (aka COSMOS, aka Spacebook).
Yes, CCP do have a knack for confusing naming schemes.
The shiniest item here is the possibility to actually manage some actual EVE game stuff on Tranquility from a web browser. In addition comes the Spacebook aspect of the New Eden web portal, that should bring us essentials like calendars, player finder and personal/corp profiles etc.
This is really promising, not so much because of CCP's own implementation of this new toolset, but because they seem really intent on expanding the out-of-game options to pull and push in-game data, which should hopefully enable interesting community-made tools to come out.

EVE Chromium (made with awesomium).
Built on top of Chromium (itself built on Apple's WebKit) the new in-game browser is of course the great enabler for New Eden and C° — bringing a 'real' browser into the game client means the same content and features can be seamlessly accessed both in and out of game (within some limits), which obviously cuts on development costs and acts as a multiplier of the total value and utility of the offer.
With full AJAX support and maybe (limited) flash capacities, it's easy to see the potential for great webtools and spectacular security breaches — good fun coming our way in both cases.

It's really hard to comment further on this aspect of Dominion, considering it's all very much in the works at this stage, and because it will only reveal its full potential once the community starts to put out tools and services leveraging the APIs and middleware behind. I'm sure there will be more to say about it by the first months of 2010, and that's definitely one of the most exciting developments around EVE to arise in a while.

Fleet Finder (a giant leap, just one foot shy of the mark).
For lack of empirical experience, I won't say more about the new Fleet Finder system, except everything about it falls somewhere between good and w00t — the only bad part being what's missing.
A pretty good dev blog details the new features and overhauled interface — recommended read.
Accessibility wise, it really will make things much easier for all types of teamplay, be it war, mission running, ratting or mining, that's the sort of tool where almost every single feature benefits all players.
The lack of ability to manage Squads and Wings as lego bricks, however, means that it will still be extremely cumbersome (and therefore practically unrealistic) to increase the granularity of fleet management under most circumstances. Making sure the various Leadership boni trickle down where they should, that the right leaders are in charge of their respective Squad/Wing and enjoy some autonomy, all will remain a headache and too time consuming to be practical.
The lack of options to seamlessly merge/split fleet blocks isn't dooming, but is a bit of a shot in the leg of that otherwise quite pretty horsey.

NPE — Newbies' Prime Endeavors.
This one I'll give its own entry as soon as I'm done figuring out what difference Dominion's will make relative to the current NPE, which isn't perfect but already has come a long way.


[Tomorrow I'll start looking into making post-Dominion less ebil for 0.0 players, and maybe others, too.]


Tuesday, October 27, 2009

You're it !

I promised yesterday I'll cover the good bits of what's coming in Dominion before I move on to offer some ideas about how to address the horribly botched parts of the design, but I got distracted toying with new feature ideas, and didn't finish this other thing, so today's downtime filler is a game of tag.


Tagging:
Overview:
Hit a target ship using a ballistic (non-homing) special 'Tag' munition to enable your ship to track it across space. It's like scanning, except you slap your personal homing beacon on the target and then chase it across the 'verse, or almost.

Mechanics:
Tagging munitions create a durable beacon on the target, that appear in both the overview and system-map for the ship that shot the munition, allowing it to track the target as it moves around and to warp to it with pinpoint accuracy.
  • Tag Probes and Tracker Bombs create a ship-to-ship link between the target and tracker. If the tracking ship pilot ejects and another pilot boards ship, the tracking will remain active for the new pilot (based on the original pilots skills, the tracking parameters being attached to the tracking ship, not pilot).
  • Tagged ships will be informed once about their status via combat message, persistent in log, but it will not blink, tweet or otherwise show in the interface or to the client after that for the duration of the tag.
  • Tracking persists through downtime and logging off or back for the duration of the tracking timer. If a tagged ship gets out of tracking range (relative to the tracker ship) then back in before its tag expires, the link will be restored automatically, enabling tracking to resume.
  • Tagging again an already tracked target with the same tracker ship and tag type will simply reset its tracking duration timer.
  • A tagged ship can still cloak, but this will not prevent the tracker ship from warping to it, including to 0 range.
  • Tag Probes and Tracker Bombs can be detected on a tagged ship by using a Ship Scanner, and can then be removed either by using a Station Repair service or a Codebreaker module in space, applied to the tagged ship.
Tag Probes:
Shot using Expanded Probe launchers, they allow tracking of up to 5 targets per tracker ship inside a solar system for a duration of 1-5h each.
Tag Probes show the tagged target(s) current name, type and location as a beacon (including closest celestial and range in AU) in the overview, system map and onboard scanner.
  • If a new target is tagged when the maximum count of tags is already tracked, the tracker ship will 'forget' the oldest track to make room for the new one.
  • Tag probes only 'stick' to targets that are under 50% shields at the time of impact. 
  • Tag probes are strictly ballistic, they will only 'stick' to a target they actually collide with.
Skill Reqs:
  • Projected ECCM lvl1 (1h/level to tracking duration)
  • Astrometric Acquisition lvl1 (+1 tagged target allowed per level)

Tracker Bombs:
Shot using regular bomb launchers by Stealth Bombers at the usual fire rate, Tracker Bombs make possible to chase a single target way beyond a solar system's limits. They will continuously report the location of a tagged ship for a duration of 2-10h, as long as it sits within 5-15 LY from the tracker ship.
Tracker Bombs show the tagged target current name, type and location (solar system and range in LY) in the overview, system map, map and onboard scanner.
  • Each Stealth Bomber electronics can only keep track of a single Tracker Bomb at a time. If a new target is tagged when one is already tracked, only the most recently tagged target will be tracked.
  • Tracker Bombs only 'stick' to targets that are under 90% shields at the time of impact. 
  • Tracker Bombs are mostly ballistic, they don't have a timer fuse and will detonate on proximity detection within 500m of the first collidable they encounter, and tag it. If nothing is met before it reaches its flight time limit, a Tracker Bomb will anticlimactically vanish.
  • Tracker Bombs can only be fired in Sec<0.4.
Skill Reqs:
  • Projected ECCM lvl1 (2h/level to tracking duration)
  • Bomb Deploymennt lvl3 (+5 LY tracking range per level above 3, base range 5LY)

Monday, October 26, 2009

How CCP handed 0.0 over to the goons.

[Continued from part 2 on Dominion]


…and there was much rejoicing.

In keeping with the spirit of the supercapitals 'fix', CCP once again demonstrates how easy it is to make things worse on 5 fronts by not thinking through the fix to one problem.

Last September the 9th saw many 0.0 players fall on their knees in ecstasy upon reading a few simple words in a Dev Blog:
"Sovereignty will no longer be tied directly to starbases."
OMG YAY !
…Then it went south.
Through several dev blogs, followed by a couple confused presentations during fanfest, CCP started unveiling what the new sovereignty system is supposed to look like — we're Oct 26th, the expansion release has been carved in stone for Dec 1st, and by all accounts, the final design for that stuff is far from frozen, meaning they expect to finalize design and have it good for production under a month time… this bodes well.

[Fair warning : Don't bother with this wall of text if you're not in one of those alliances already big and rich enough to sustain a megablob of SuperCarriers (pfrrt… this never gets old): Dominion will ensure you'll stick for the foreseeable future to Empire space where SuperCapitals aren't allowed — unless you fancy "pet" as a nickname.]


Dominion Sovereignty at a glance.
  • The sovereignty flagpole count per system goes down from N (between 1 and total # of moons in system) to one, and is now a player-deployed structure anchored near a planet that becomes functional (and invulnerable) 24h after launch time, thereafter granting sovereignty to the owner faction.
    • Sovereignty is challenged by deploying anchorables (disruptor fields) around stargates in system (at this writing 1/2 +1 of stargates # in system), which will render the flagpole vulnerable to attack after 12h of continuous occupation of the stargates with disruptor fields, then by destroying the flagpole to lift sovereignty on the system.
    • Once the system is returned to unclaimed state, it becomes possible to anchor a new flagpole to reclaim sovereignty.

  • Sovereignty levels are removed, and perks like constellation capital immunity with them.

  • Outposts are the new POS:
    • OP are captured by getting shot at enough, which kicks in a reinforced mode, then a second pass of shooting is required to finally seize the outpost… sounds familiar ?
    • Outpost control is no longer dependent on holding sovereignty, but informs whether the flagpole can be rendered vulnerable to damage — in short, if an outpost is present, then the OP must be captured prior to kicking down the flagpole — presumably you still need sovereignty in first place to deploy a new outpost.


  • System upgrades: The sovereignty holder can deploy a new "System Upgrade" structure (separate from the sov flagpole), that allows the installation of power-ups for the entire system. [Hopefully only the owner faction reaps the benefits, but I sense fun bugs ahead]
    • System upgrades are divided by fields and ranks, and will allow an alliance to boost PvE resources (more/better rats, wormholes, exploration sites), enable the deployment of industrial/tactical/logistics advanced modules on POSes (cynogen/jammers, bridges, capital assembly arrays, etc.) or extra abilities for outposts (SuperCarriers parking).
    • CCP is undecided at this stage whether system upgrades vanish when sovereignty is lost/seized, or if they can be reclaimed by the conqueror as spoils of war.

  • A new Treaty system is underway, which is intended to help formalize relationships between an alliance and third-party corps or alliances. Main stated goals are to ease standings management, and allow alliances to formally rent or loan estate in their space to non-member corporations. This part being even fuzzier than the rest of the big-item features of Dominion, it's hard to comment on specifics (see more below about the implications, though).

  • New Upkeep fees are put in place, that space-owning alliances will have to acquit for each of their systems. The stated intent is to discourage alliances from hoarding space they don't use via fiscal pressure.

  • In semi-separate news, the revenue of moon mining is somewhat rebalanced by changing the recipes for many T2 items in order to favor lower-rarity materials, and Alchemy (which enables one to cook rare materials by combining less-rare ones) sees its output boosted significantly (x3 to x5 last time I heard).

Now, for the fun part…
The stated design goals for the Dominion sovereignty rewrite, as far as I can gather from various panels, dev blogs, forum posts and presentations:

1.— Get rid of POS warfare, especially of the spam flavor:

Arguably check, and a welcome while long-overdue change, although the lack of imagination displayed with the 'new' outpost capture mechanics (essentially a POS-like system with some random factor thrown in the duration of reinforced mode) is disappointing.

2.— Discourage 'afk alliances' and make room for new colors and more conflict on the map:

The notion of imposing diminishing returns and progressive penalties on alliances that hold more than N-value space, it's not entirely off-mark, except for two things:
3.— Make territorial warfare more 'cerebral' (I'm not making this up) to break the blob, also sovereignty is now 'descriptive, rather than prescriptive' (not kidding either).

Assuming my translation of T0rfi-speak is not too far off, 'more cerebral' territorial warfare is to be understood as 'less of a rail-guided race', and there were also some wishful words about it reducing blobbery.
Since we all know a blob is a faceless and brainless way to win wars, I guess CCP fallaciously concluded that invoking 'cerebral' as a power-word would magically shoo the blob away. Let me know how that works out for you next time you try to stop an incoming train by standing very still and using nothing but the power of your brain.

If you've read the summary of Dominion sovereignty mechanics above, one thing is obvious: there is neither obligation nor incentive to split the blob across multiple locales in system, much less across several systems.
  • As an attacker: enemy outposts are vulnerable at all times, so the obvious optimal path is to steamroll each and every foreign outpost system in sequence down to reinforced mode, while dropping disruption fields at every gate on the way, just for kicks ; then take it again from the top right on time to finish the outposts off, and presto, you have evicted the locals from their space housing.

  • As a defender: cycle-blobbing each gate in turn should be a viable strategy to waste hostile onlining disruptor fields, thus repeatedly resetting the 12h timer, negating the impact of outpost losses on your sovereignty's defense— not that it will do you much good, as we'll see in a moment.
If the attacker ever manages to lift flagpole invulnerability by smartly playing timezone offsets with its disruptor fields, the next obligatory move (that would be prescriptive in Greyscalespeak) is a giant dogpile over the flagpole — that's every ship in presence forcibly duking it out inside one grid. Good times.

The predictable pattern resulting from the confrontation of reasonably matched contenders is quite a few outposts ping-ponging every couple days, regardless of sovereignty, which becomes rather meaningless.
In the case of unevenly-matched contenders, and immediately after the local outpost has been surprise-raped, the blob will split, indeed, to the tune of one blob per gate until it's time for the aforementioned giant dogpile on the flagpole. Expect quite a lot of that.
Fun fact: the blob was already split over gates during an invasion, in order to control access to the system, so the benefits of this model in terms of blob-splitting hotspots count are exactly — count'em — zero.
Interestingly, assuming CCP goes for the option of not allowing capture of the 'Upgrade center' and instead decides to have it go poof on sovereignty shift, it may be more interesting for an invader to entirely ignore sovereignty and be content to focus on seizing outposts, leaving for the defender to pay Upkeep bills while the attackers milk the juicy NPCs attracted by the now-homeless defenders' system upgrades.

I'm sure a great many wars won descriptively through cerebral harassment tactics applied to renters by swarms (not blobs) is exactly what CCP had in mind when they came up with this design — they, the goons lovers.
Oh, poetic justice.


[On a lighter note, I'll cover tomorrow some of the more promising among Dominion features, and after that, I'll move away from pointing and laughing to offer some possible solutions to the 0.0 clusterfuck. Stay tuned.]

Sunday, October 25, 2009

CCP School of Design — The Drinking Game

[Continued from part 1 on Dominion]

Sovereignty mechanics is serious bizness, possibly the single largest can of worms of nullsec, and a matter better handled carefully by EVE designers, as the very attraction and credibility of EVE as a sandbox model hinge on whether playing the 0.0 end game is worth a damn.

Ever since someone came up with the brilliant idea to use POSes as sovereignty flagpoles 5 years ago, CCP's ears have been ringing about how this thing was getting increasingly, eye-gougingly painful and — what's worse — boring and unfun to play. It is fair to assume assume CCP took those concerns at heart and have been working relentlessly to ensure that, by its next iteration sovereignty contests resolution would be playable, tactically stimulating and, above all, engrossing and fnu.

Certainly the time it took them to come up with an answer was an indicator of CCP's intent to get it right this time, and to not make things worse by upsetting further the already precarious sanity of those players who had been submitted to years of alarm-clock ops, buggy POS mechanics and their assorted exploits, nightmares-inducing tower-spam wars, and paid $15 a month to 'play' Slideshow Online blobfests.

Judging from what SiSi and other sources of information can teach us about the current state of things, one can only imagine how seriously CCP went about the arduous process of bringing us Dominion on time for Iceland's Sovereignty Day (the wit ! these guys pack fists full of awesome).

Midbörg, Reykjavik — late August 2009.

— Wow, I can't believe it was that easy to do away with the POS thing… we should have done that years ago.

— You tell me ? OK, what's next on the list ?

— Hmm, everybody's whining about the sovereignty systems being too static and that a few mega-blocks are hoarding all the map for themselves, doing nothing with most of it.

— Yeah but they need the space to feed their blobs.

— Right, let's give'em powerups to get more food in less space, that way we'll make room for more alliances.

— Hmm, sounds nifty, but what stops them from just hoarding unused space anyway ?

— I know, let's tax them up the wazoo for every system they claim !

— Wow brilliant, mate ! That'll show'em. Let's remove constellation sovereignty and capital immunity, too, that will make for more action !

— Cool beans ! Outposts too. Who said outposts couldn't be shot while sovereignty is active…

— Er… we did. Wasn't station ping-pong the coolest thing, though ?

— Not really. We need some kind of delaying feature to avoid that in the future.

— Me ! me ! me ! *waves hand frantically* …we could have a safety mechanism that renders the outpost invulnerable for a while after it's taken serious damage, and then you wait, like, 12h or so before you can finish it of. …this way the defenders have time to regroup and meet the assailants for an Epic fight to the end !

— Two words: awe-some !

— This last bit reminds me of something… whatever, it's cool.

— Won't that be a problem for new and small alliances… I mean, between the taxes, no capital immunity, paying for all the outposts and upgrades, it will be almost impossible to reach critical mass before being steamrolled by any big alliance that needs to stretch its legs, no ?

— Hmm…

— Yeah, I see what you mean…

— er…

— What if… bear with me guys — if we allowed big alliances to host small ones… like, *rent* systems, so they can do their stuff and be protected, and pay the big alliance for that ?

— That'd work. In fact, it's cool, it's a win-win scenario, and with your stupid nerfing of r64s, my guys can use the extra income if we are to build all those SuperCarriers.

— hehe…

— That name sucks, btw.

— …

— lolcat !

— …no, really, I think the rental thing is the way to go. It's EVE, see: might makes right and darwin and shit ! I mean… if they can't make it on their own, they deserve to be pets !

— Good point. Pets it is then.

— Are we on fire or what ? I knew we'd be done with this thing by the end of happy hour.

That's just me guessing — it could have been worse.

Saturday, October 24, 2009

Is this thing on ?

Nearly a full year since I last chimed in on the wonderful nightmare that is EVE online, frankly because I had lost hope in CCP to ever improve their ways, and after a while simply lost the steam to remain pissed off about this waste of a potentially great game.

Thanks to all those rank 8+ skills, I don't need to log in more often than every other month on any account, and staying clear of EVE has been easy enough, until a friend recently poked me, all excited about this winter's expansion.
— Can you believe it, they're fixing sovereignty ! … and bloody titans too ! *cartwheels*
— Uh oh…
It's no secret I'm one of those people whose creativity is more easily fueled by frustration than anything else, in a 'necessity is a mother of invention' sort of way, and it comes with a bitchy propensity to notice that yes, this skirt makes your ass look fat. In my defense, I don't hold their large buttocks against people as long as they don't put them in my face while bragging about having the tiniest, cutest derriere.


Are you ready for fists full of awesome ?
Titans' infamous one-click-buy
pwn button finally gets a hefty smack of the nerfbat, which is good news, and kind of a big deal for the 99% of the nullsec players who don't happen to fly one, who will finally get a chance to load local before they get vaporized across the grid.
On the minus side, titans have been grossly imbalanced since release, late 2005 (give 6 months before they started to show up for real in game), so that's a charitable 3 years CCP took to work the problem before bringing out a solution (with great fanfare) during this month's FanFest… this better be good.

The titan, this beast of war, the herald of doom, the flagship to rally your troops and lead them to glorious mayhem, entirely revamped over the course of 3 years of inspired research, now with:
…a gun.


Beige is the new pink.
You've read it right: CCP's answer to the problem of a game-breaking overpowered AoE weapon is to remove the game breaking AoE weapon… and replace it with a slow-loading Big Bertha cannon. …and that's that, move along folks, nothing to see here.
Oh wait, the ka-boom graphics for the new guns will be awesome, I swear ! That should count for something, right ?
Yeah, you've got cool graphic artists, and game designer at CCP is a fallback position for your best buddies after they get spanked in-game and lose their intarweb spaceships kingdom.

Meanwhile, Motherships have been renamed SuperCarriers (ta-daa !), because we all know the best way to address the fact you can't design your way out of a rusty matari shack and get a ship to live up to its intended role is to: rechristen it with a name so ridiculous a third class Decepticon would refuse to go on screen with it, give it a poorly-thought SuperPower, then move the goalpost back to the place where you've left your design ambitions to rot, and claim victory.


WTFPwnMobile 2.0
While the titan's fix is at least functional, if uninspired, the SuperCarriers will pick up the slack of XtremeImbalance and use it to slap Dreadnaughts (sic) pilots everywhere across their collective face, thanks to Fighter Bombers, whose exactly unique purpose is to destroy capital ships and look very cool while doing so. Yay.

Let's recap: the titan was broken because it was a one-man-army grid-wiper, which is now sorted by the restriction imposed on titans to pick a single stain on their windscreen to scratch at once. Meanwhile, the Mothership, once a glorified, overpriced carrier and shit-magnet is now becoming a one-man-anticapital-army which, in one fell swoop…
  • makes carriers largely obsolete: it can do almost everything they do, only better (don't mention triage on carriers unless you've tried it) ;
  • will singlehandedly wtfpwn dreads, unless fighter-bombers are underpowered, in which case the SuperCarriers will prove as overpriced and useless as Motherships used to be ;
  • will do the job of dreads, which CCP explicitly intends to be good for nothing but shoot structures and maybe sieged capitals (while SuperCarriers don't have to sit tight to pwn), and which ought to become largely pointless in Dominion.
…I'll get back to that last bit in a minute, but take my word for it until then: we're not killing POSes anymore (which is good, sorta).


SuperCarrier: baddest ship ever, or worst ship ever ?
Of course, SuperCarriers — it's really, really hard to type that name with a straight face — will cost a lot of ISK, about 8 to 9 dreads' worth, fitted (10 tops, assuming Fighter Bombers come pricey enough), so that should leave a good niche for Dreads, right ?
Yes indeed, until enough SCs get produced. Assuming a single SuperCarrier packs enough punch to match even 5-6 dreads, the ISK tradeoff is a bargain: every single capital pilot flying one of those will have the output of 5+ focus-firing dreads at his disposal, which is enough to make short order of individual targets (dreads or carriers) by himself, and all that without committing to the 10-minutes risk window of a siege mode.

Simply put, ISK is easier to come by than reliable capital pilots (ie, who show up on ops and aren't spies): any alliance that can afford to bring 5x the amount of pain with the same head count of players won't blink twice at the tenfold increase in ISK expense. The extra flexibility of still being able to field regular Fighters (and maybe drones) will ensure a SuperCarrier can be put to good use against anything bigger than a cruiser, right after it's done shredding the enemy's hoi-polloi of Dreads and Carriers.
Wishfully, CCP trusts the removal of available insurance policies for SuperCapitals will balance that, somehow — although I suspect a good proportion of Mothership pilots never realized that (with a friendly GM assist) it *was* possible to insure their epeenmobile, until now.

Our best hope at this stage is for SuperCarriers to be (pre?)nerfed enough to pack less punch than 5 dreads, so they end up as overpricey, useless and underused as Motherships… yeah, sad to hope for a ship to suck, but better than the opposite in this case.

Why is that a problem, besides infuriating the hordes of dreadnought pilots that will now have to convert to the largely separate skill-tree of oober-carrierism ?
Well, my friend, I hate to break it to you, but the Fighter Bombers arz in ur space stealing ur jobs — it's outsourcing to the robots !

Every time a ship comes out that qualifies as a one-man-army, the richer among EVE players get an extra advantage, leveraging ISK as a replacement for manpower, and thus reducing the number of roles to fill in the fleet command chain. This could be a good thing if this was capped somehow, but when you introduce ships that are better in every way but price (within acceptable limits of cost), you pretty much force all players to jump on the bandwagon to meet the new 'minimal requirements'.

The SuperCarrier is the new Dreadnought cum Carrier cum Battleship, get used to it… See you tomorrow for the kicker.

Meanwhile, yes CCP, you do look fat in this skirt.

Saturday, November 8, 2008

CSM - 2nd edition.

I've hinted before at my views on the CSM, and on CCP's agenda and handling of the thing being more than a little ambiguous, but nonetheless, the second CSM representative ballot is worth a few lines of commentary.

Launched in the wake of the 2007 BoB/T20/Kugutsuman scandal (along with IA), the CSM was initially pitched as council of ombudsmen whose establishment was supposed to restore the userbase faith in CCP's business ethics, and convince players undue interference from staffers in in-game disputes, as well as GM/Dev to player cronyism/collusion were not only a thing of the past, but even in times of yore had seldom been a factual truth.

Before the first CSM went live, however, this part of the pitch had been mercifully dropped, probably because the practicality of a semi-random bunch of players — selected on the basis of forum popularity and alliance player count — auditing a R-POW operator for potential maladministration is a can of worms even CCP isn't clueless enough to not foresee exploding in their face.

CSM was thus re-branded as a plebeian consultative council of sorts, whose defined role is to relay players' concerns, prayers for changes and improvements to the game (yet strictly in-game, as it has been made clear that any discussion by the CSM of price policies, business model, community management or work ethics are off the table).

The unstated expectation on CCP's part is to draw CSM reps into the inner circle of fanbois, and leverage their assumed 'street cred' for community PR as user-friendly agents of the Ministry of Truth, since any word typed with a CCP staff signature on the forum is automatically cursed with an aura of half-competent weaselry and DoubleSpeak.

Of course, the fun begins with CCP, voters, CSM candidates and past representatives all holding different sets of expectations about the CSM purpose and capacities.

Most 0.0 alliance players don't give it a second thought and will vote with the party line (if any), reading the CSM election for what it is, ie an opportunity to buy their faction's champion a seat at the table, and a chance to represent them on a select metagaming battlefield.

Some of the wide-eyed n00bs to the EVE political game will eagerly vote for whoever ressembles them most, or seems knowledgeable, or competent, or cute, and will waste their voice like a tree-hugger gay negro commie at an Alaskian ballot.

…and most of the players simply won't vote, because they don't care or don't trust the CSM to be of any influence, unless decide to play along and cast a voice in favor of a 'safe' public figure, such as Chribba or Morning Maniac (neither of which is on the roster for this election, just examples).

Interestingly, although the most prominent warring factions are somewhat represented by candidates bearing their colors*, very few alliance leaders have taken the plunge by running themselves, or even officially endorsing a candidate.
BoB leadership, for example, is nowhere to be seen, but possibly via a couple of their famed pets.

Whether this should be interpreted as a fear of embarrassment over a possible failure in a popularity contest, a strategic choice of running with candidates who enjoy plausible deniability against accusations of partisan bias, or as simple disenfranchisement or disavowal of the CSM as a whole is left as an exercise for the reader.

As for me, I voted with my army of alts, and I didn't spread the love much across contenders.
My understanding of the model is that the CSM is of some minor relevance at this stage, and can possibly have a marginal positive influence in pointing problems and solutions to the dev team's attention, yet mostly based on the interpersonal quality of the connection any given CSM representative will be able to build with his council mates — and more importantly with select CCP staffers.

The CSM is basically an officially endorsed lobby club on every other topic, with just as much influence as the feudal approach of CCP to the matter allows, and it brings absolutely nothing to the community on the issues of accountability, fair governance, and drunk driving in the conduct of business… not that I'm saying it should, while I feel for the poor souls who delude themselves in that hope, assuming that level of candor is to be found among the voting player base.

* The NC has more than a few runners, and goons have no less than 7 declared candidates in the race, out of a total selection of 43.

Thursday, November 6, 2008

Ghost training — Winter Expansion !

Well, not really, just a minor update, but it's what all the cool kids do nowadays, so I figured I'd make it look big, too.

Over two weeks since the asinine planking of Ghost Training, and the whine thread is still going strong, having now broken the 180 pages and 5400 posts mark, and plowing ahead at a steady pace.

How CCP managed to turn the most fanatical fanboi userbase into an army of bitter ex-wives will probably win them another "Special" paragraph in the history of R-POWs… never has the irony of the Crowd Control Production brand been so biting.

What should happen happens, people consolidate their accounts, drop alts and switch from $$ to playmoney because they simply don't want to commit to the game publisher's future anymore.

The financial impact must slowly start to be perceptible, as accounts reach the end of their subs and don't get renewed, and it will only get worse, if my own sample is any indication: I've slated 6 accounts for hibernation already, but since some are well-fed, only two will show on CCP's stats as missing before the end of this month, while the rest are to limp till jan/feb on their prepaid subs, until they go to sleep more or less permanently.

Is it really because of Ghost Training ?
Only indirectly in my case.

Really, don't start a rescue playmoney fundraiser on my behalf just yet: as long as general inflation follows the price of GTCs at an acceptable pace, I'll keep making more than I need to feed whichever accounts I feel like keeping alive.
My position is a favored one, as I'm only dropping what could be called spare accounts so far: old ones that aren't really used on a regular basis but you keep alive for variety's sake or sentimental reasons.

I'm not shutting those down because I lost the ability to Ghost Train them, as I barely ever used the feature but by accident (letting an account lapse until I try to log it on and figure it's inactive, or EVEmon blinks stupidly while trying to sync on it), and a couple times during a week-to-month vacation from EVE.

I'm shutting those down because I don't really have a use for them right now, when CCP is building up for their own private financial crisis inside EVE without fully realizing it, and I'm bracing myself for the crash — all my accounts run on GTCs.

At current GTC rates, 6 accounts amount to 1.5b ISK savings monthly, which I hope will suffice for me to ride out the predictable raise of GTC for ISK prices as the GTC offer/demand ratio plummets in the next couple months — until inflation (and my revenue) catches up (if they do, which is unsure).
This trend of GTC ISK prices rocketing up as an isolated commodity can only be accelerated by an increase in RMT'ing, as people get pressured to get the most ISK for their buck to pay for their GTCs, compounded by the risky nature of RMT'ing and the foreseeable hysteria of CCP USSS over it, which should fuel the urgency to make the most of what amounts to a capital crime in EVE world (bannable offense).

Will I be selling my 'dead' accounts ?
No… at least not yet.

There's no real reason to think they may lose ISK value as the average SP count raises, since the character category hit the hardest by Ghost Training removal (growth wise) is the high-SP specialist population.

Fewer people will train new dread pilots without Ghost Training, for ex, considering their very limited/specialized role compared to the huge time sinks involved in bringing a toon from a very good sub-capital skill-set to a lousy capital one.
[This alone is a serious issue, as new players are once again getting the shaft while old timers like me benefit from an historical edge of accrued benefits, now boosted further by an artificially raised barrier to entry.]

Most of my accounts host at least 60m SP spread across 1-2 chars…
Any specialty depending on leaping wide training-time gaps to see any progression is likely to shrink in relative numbers, as proportionally fewer characters embrace those careers.
If anything, my semi-useless veteran toons will be worth more in a few months, after the panic fire sales, when the offer of high-SP chars starts dwindling and people realize they should hold onto what is essentially becoming a non-renewable resource.

What does that mean for CCP's revenue ?
Well, not much… on a micro-scale.

6 accounts worth of GTCs dropping is just 105$/month of revenue loss, arguably a drop in the ocean ; yet CCP just lost my (and I suspect a few others') most profitable drop in the ocean.

I'm disabling accounts that used to translate into near-zero server load (mostly skill switches, and the occasional ride around the block), and am now only contributing to CCP's operating costs with accounts that generate an above average load on servers (capital pilots crashing nodes, mass traders with bazillions of market orders, builders/researchers hoarding up to 66 slots of S&I worth of queries per acct, etc.).

You Maniacs! You blew it up! Ah, damn you! God damn you all to hell!

There's a saying in the service business that the best customer is one that pays his fee and never uses the service. True to themselves, CCP is making sure to drive those customers away before any other.

Also in true CCP fashion, and after enough clue-by-four has been applied to their chewy parts that they start having problems sitting comfortably, they show how good they are at taking a hint, coming clean and learning from their mistakes by reintroducing the 30d GTCs to he game in the most convoluted (yet brilliant, as stated here) way.

They're now halfway through fixing the very first crater from the GTC bombing, but went for the wrong half: bringing back 30d GTC subs without a price correction to match regular 1-month plans, and/or bundling some form of hooking susbtance with it (shameless plug) will not break the spiral of doom acceleration.

People still lack an incentive to spend their money on GTCs rather than RMT, and notwithstanding Oveur being happy-happy with his catchphrase about in-game trade of ETCs supposedly "Cramping down on RMTs style with a kill and a smile", this claim unfortunately has about as much substance as a Sarah Palin speech on monetary economics.

Looking at the horse's teeth (because it's a damn pricey horse).

The one thing that makes in-game ETC trade sexeh and worthwile is it magically 'materializes' time (the ultimate postmodern commodity) into a transferable token.

From the horse's mouth, about the new in-game ETC trade:
  • Lower barrier of entry for exchanging ETCs. Everybody can do it easily in-game [True]

  • ETCs now use a transparent and efficient market, our very own EVE market [True, yet filler]

  • Fights price fixing--one of the single most complained about issues with the current secure exchange [True and false, this is a blown-up issue, with a real fix to an unreal problem]

  • Opens up for a larger supply, lowering the ISK exchange rate in the long run as anyone can exchange their ETCs more easily [Blatantly false due to inherent scarcity of ETCs in a seller-led market configuration]

  • Enables you to create corporate Contracts for your members in exchange for Pilot Licenses [True, and sexeh as hell]

  • Empowers you to recruit new players on trial into your corporations with Pilot Licenses [True, and sexeh as hell]

  • Allows you to give someone a "free beer" (I like this part) [I like it, too — although it only repeats the two previous pitch points.]

  • Cramps down on RMTs (Real Money Traders) style with a kill and a smile [delusional at best, see below]

  • It‘s pure awesome [Is that supposed to make a point ?]
What's pure awesome is how easily one can foresee RMT'ers not caring one bit about the in-game trade of ETC.

The simple and only influence ETC trade has over RMT is to inform the top and bottom of the exchange rates vs $$.
  • ETC ISK price/time: portion of in-game revenue devoted to paying for game time.
  • ETC $$ price/time: $$ <-> ISK exchange rate indexed on CCP GTC price.
Last time I checked, a 60d GTC was going for about 500m ISK, which translates in 250m ISK per 'EVE month' (30d sharp period), and was selling for 17.5$, giving us a CCP exchange rate of 14.286m ISK/$, or 0.07$/million ISK.
Meanwhile, $->ISK by RMT shops is in the 28.57m ISK/$ range, or 0.035$/million ISK.

As long as RMT'ers can offer a significantly better $->ISK exchange rate to their customers, that's revenue that will evade CCP's wallet — with a kill and a smile.
To bring those exchange rates on level, and hope to break the back of RMT shops, the in-game price of the 30d ETC would have to climb to 500m, bringing the daily in-game upkeep cost of an account to 16.67 million ISK.
…all that, assuming the RMT'ers don't fight back by offering more ISK for a $ than they do now.

As explained earlier, I agree with Oveur that the ISK price of GTCs is likely to go up, hard, and I imagine in CCP's Economia FantasyLand they're betting on it to reduce the gap between state-approved exchange rates and black market, thus driving ISK buyers away from RMT'ers.

Although CCP's hardline-free-market advocates going all USSR on exchange rates is quite funny, it's nonetheless naive and doomed, knowing most RMT shops currently buy a billion ISK for around 22-25$, and reap at least 30% profit (accounting for in-game overhead such as banned accounts etc.), doing nothing but arbitrage — I have a hunch RMT shops won't close doors before their $ gross is cut by at least half, and they can bank on the desperation of ISK-for-$ sellers to take some of the margin heat by consenting to lower buying prices from RMT shops, down to 10-15$ per billion.

Welcome to HooverVille Online™, Reykjavik county.

16.67m ISK/day turns EVE into a pure grinding game for those people who depend on mundane hunting-gathering PvE to make a pixel living, if they can even scrounge it anymore.

Not only does the grind detract from player enjoyment (and thus motivation to keep playing), but such a radical raise of the in-game cost of upkeep (with no matching boost on average in-game income) is the best way to drive the consumer economy down the crapper.

The foreseeable impact of this is a reinforcement of austerity patterns in consumer economy, with people living hand-to-mouth, cutting on all non-necessary expenses and looking harder for any ISK-saving opportunity.
Thus putting the RMT exchange at a comparative advantage, despite a possible reduction in price gap between ETC and RMT.
…oopsie.

En route to oblivion, double time !

Eventually, CCP's scroched-earth economic wizardry will indeed hurt RMT'ers , to the extent that less ISK overall is burned by a reduced number of active accounts, but if that's CCP's idea of a solution to RMT, we're facing a solid enough case of killing the patient to get to the disease to warrant a very formal: WTF?!

My guess is RMT'ers may bring the fight to the in-game ETC market before then, and corner it by leveraging their huge ISK liquidities and the worsening scarcity of ETC offers.
That opens juicy opportunities for price fixing on a meta-scale, and I foresee RMT'ers offering ETC+ISK bundles in their OOG online shops soon enough — at prices that will have CCP scratching their heads in disbelief.

That is, of course, unless CCP comes up with a yet-another brand of medecine, but what could it be, one must wonder ?

ETC — in game trading (and other, less important stuff).

One word: wicked.

Listed on the Quantum Rise expansion features page is a little gem, right at the bottom, that probably will have more impact on the EVE universe than any of the other over-hyped stuff in this expansion (bar the underway server yaardware improvements): in-game ETC trade.

The same feature is covered at length in Oveur's latest devblog (a devblog is CCP's 21st century idea of a .plan entry, as copy-proofed by the Ministry of Truth).

Those with a memory better than a fruit fly's will remember the hot issue of ETC/GTCs and their relation to RMT and CCP customer retention discussed in this article, followed by a proposed fix for the Ghost Training feature (nice work of NewSpeak on retro-naming this feature, which I forgot to mention at the time, btw.).

Sadly Ghost Training isn't rezzed, and that's a shame, but IG ETC trade is just brilliant and I hate myself for not having brought it up.

The general idea of a better integration with the in-game trade is sort of obvious, and I sniffed this could plug in nicely as a new category of in-game contract (with the upcoming improvements in that area), but the idea to turn time into an actual tradeable token, as in Item is freakin' genius: it talks directly to the Oh shiney ! part of the brain that has people jump like poodles through every cool marketing hoop, and I salute this with the topical humility of one who lacks that kind of vision.

I'd go into detail on other stuff in Quantum Rise, but sadly there isn't much to say about this expansion: the fact every "feature" has to be re-hashed three times, and still needs screenshots thumbnails as filler to barely make up one screen page says enough about the anemic nature of this release, which reeks of "We don't have shit to show guys… — Well, it's this time of the year, we gotta slap that WinterXpansion! sticker on something: gimme whatever's planned for next hotfix, that'll do."

On second thought, there's so little content in there that I can cover it in a few lines:
  • Weapon grouping: Cool stuff usability-wise, and the servers will certainly love the drastic cut on transactions and to-hit virtual dice rolls.

    Oh, also movable HUD (that's the blinky thing in the bottom center of the screen), and cycle timers on weapons/mods. Well, no, it wasn't there yet.


  • Certificates: I haven't looked into those in depth, but they look promising from a usability standpoint, could help people find their way more easily in the mazelike skill tree, and may be a nice recruitment/HR management tool for corps if integrated in the job advertising system.

  • Medals: OK, I'm not the target audience for eye-candy, so I'm not overly excited about this, but I suspect the people who fancy pixel trinkets won't get an orgasm over this either, because from the screenies, those medals are 1996 cheap-ass, butt-ugly, and about as exotic and exciting as a forced vacation in a Swiss Postal Services retirement home.

  • New Stargates: Seriously, that's it ? I'm at a loss for words. They look cute, but c'mon: last time an EVE expansion was about eyecandy it was this.

  • Alchemy: Short version, crappy moons can now yield a crappy amount of yummy stuff (with much waste and effort), whereas high-end moon reactions used to be the exclusive of a happy few top-tier moon owners in select regions. Not a bad change in itself, but the kind of band-aid half-assed fix that I fear will delay a much-needed overhaul of the PvE resource distribution on TQ, so not exactly a win either.

  • Orca: 1 year old semi-smart design finally hits the live server, yelling all the way down: "I swear, I'm not just filler !". Certainly not a game changer, but why not, although it could break further the already gimped Rorqual.

  • Bombs: now cheaper. That's it, move along people.

  • New music tracks: They could be absolutely entrancing, but I wouldn't know. Like 99% of EVE players, the first thing I do on a fresh install is to disable audio. I feel sorry for the poor guy writing tracks nobody ever listens.

  • Improved travel: Already released for what it is: a load balancing fix getting Jita and other traffic jams out of your autopilot, more or less. Welcome to 1998 and onboard GPS in your 33rd century Warship, at last.

  • Assembly Array Upgrades: I've been checking those on SiSi, and I won't comment yet, because they're really a balancing/tweaking type of job, and I want to believe that's still a work in progress (or expect the same entry to make for another glorified Feature ! in the next pseudo-Expansion).

  • Speed rebalanced: See Assembly Arrays above, very much still in the oven, and certainly a controversial one, no matter what CCP comes up with. Tweaking speed, tank or DPS in EVE is like pushing a new fiscal plan in meatspace: half the population will hate your guts no matter what, so I'm not about to shoot the ambulance until this is stamped as Gold.
Although none of those features are inherently bad, and in fact are actually nice and welcome, they file for the most part under cosmetic fixes and/or solid cases of stuff that should have been in the box, and while they would have found their rightful place in an expansion worth its salt, they definitely don't make for one on their lone self.
One has to wonder if CCP has hired people from Microsoft OS/Office division as product line managers.

To be fair, Oveur's devblog (mentioned above) hints at more ongoing changes and additions, and I'm not saying CCP is slacking. More likely I suspect the semestrial expansion model isn't exactly suited to the kind of material they're hammering right now, and — as often with CCP — the dooming part is less in what they bring to the game than in the way they bring it.

Here, new content that would be a very nice bag of cookies if released as a Thanksgiving Bonus Patch only looks pale for being wrapped in the overblown package of a Winter Expansion it simply can't fill.

And yeah, I haven't posted much lately, neither here or anywhere really, but it's not for lack of motivation, just information overload and other stuff to do in meatspace.

ttfn.